Elephants and Mice Revisited: Law and Choice of Law on the Internet
نویسندگان
چکیده
By definition, an essential question of cyberlaw is to define when law will affect actions in cyberspace. Such law might be uniform, such as where nations have entered into a treaty or have adopted the same legal rule. Or, such law might be diverse, such as where nations adopt different legal rules. Diversity of law often does not matter for physical acts, such as where the criminal law of one country simply does not apply to acts performed in a foreign country. On the Internet, however, diversity of law poses a fundamental challenge. Each surfer on a website might be from a foreign jurisdiction, with laws unknown to the owner of the site. Similarly, each website visited by a surfer might be hosted in a foreign jurisdiction, with laws unknown to the surfer. Every encounter in cyberspace, therefore, raises the possibility that diverse laws will apply. The rules for choosing among diverse laws—the subject of this part of the Symposium on “Choice of Law and Jurisdiction on the Internet”—thus appear uniquely important for cyberspace. Surprisingly, however, the number of actual cases addressing choice of law on the Internet is far, far lower than the initial analysis would suggest. Although there is the possibility of diverse national laws in every Internet encounter, some mysterious mechanisms are reducing the actual conflicts to a handful of cases. This Article seeks to explain those mysterious mechanisms. It does not primarily address the prescriptive task of saying what the optimal rules should be for resolving conflicting national laws that affect the Internet. Instead, it takes on a descriptive task. It treats choice of law on the Internet as a dependent variable; the task is to explain when and how choice-of-law rules actually matter on the Internet.
منابع مشابه
Application of Lex Mercatoria as Applicable Law in International Commercial Arbitration
In settling disputes regarding international commercial arbitration the parties may instead of choosing the law of one country to choose lex mercatoria or the law of merchants as a applicable law to the disputes. When this choice is possible that applicable choice of law rules recognize such power for the parties. The principle of autonomy is choosing lex mercatoria has been recognized in many ...
متن کاملInternet Banking Law: An Iranian Perspective Problems and Prospects of Introducing Islamic Microfinance in Azerbaijan Republic
Bank supervision and monetary policy are strategic concepts in the economy of countries. Development of electronic communications, especially in online and international spheres, has largely threatened financial services in view of security and illegal access to banking networks. Anonymity and identity theft has endangered electronic commerce by crimes like phishing, fraud and different types...
متن کاملFundamental Issues in Criminalization of Virtal Cybercrime
This paper tries to investigate the question of how virtual cybercrimes fall within the realm of criminal law and what their principles and conditions of criminalization are. Despite the large number of Internet users in virtual worlds, such as "Second Life", there has been limited literature and research especially on the extent and scope of the issue, the identity of the perpetrators and vict...
متن کاملهمسویی رویکرد قانونگذاری ایران با مقررات بینالمللی در حوزه حقوق مالکیت ادبی و هنری
In literary and artistic property law, according to the principle of independence of sovereign governments, each nation, according to local conditions and requirements and considered policies, regulatory for the protection of creators of literary and artistic works and of holders of neighboring rights. However, differences in national laws due to differences in approaches, policies and his deve...
متن کاملCases of Limitation and Deviation from the Principles of Ethical and Criminal Law through the Study of the Cause of Crimes against Security on the Basis of Expediency
Background: In specific criminal law, security crimes are of special importance for the whole society and the country due to their harmful effects on the public. One of these cases is the study of evidence in crimes against security that the manner and method of detection and investigation of perpetrators of crimes against security is different from other crimes. The purpose of explaining the c...
متن کامل